X-ray Tubes

Topics Index

  1. Back to Module Index
  2. Introduction
  3. The Cathode and the Anode
  4. The X-ray Tube
  5. X-ray Circuits
  6. Electron Accelerators
  7. Check Your Progress
  8. Your Task
  9. Glossary

Introduction

The modern X-ray tube has evolved from the early studies of electrical discharges through gases. These studies found that as the gas pressure in the discharge tube was reduced, the gases started to conduct. This conduction gave rise to a glow over the walls of the tube. By replacing the cold cathode of the discharge tube with an electrically heated filament, it was found that the filament provided a source of electrons that were drawn to the anode. Wilhelm Roentgen discovered in 1895 that a type of radiation was emitted from the anode in these discharge tubes, and that this radiation could pass through solid objects and darken photographic plates.

After completing this task, you should be able to:

Back To Top


The Cathode and the Anode

The cathode is the source of electrons. The cathode is a coiled tungsten filament mounted in a shaped electrode, called the ‘focusing cup’. The focusing cup acts to focus the electrons into a beam by electrostatic forces.

In early X-ray tubes the anode was made of solid tungsten which became white hot because most of the energy of the impinging electrons was converted to heat. The copper anode with the embedded tungsten target was developed to enable excess heat to be conducted away.

In many X-ray tubes the anode is surrounded by a hood. This hood serves several purposes:

Note that apertures in the hood are needed to allow electrons to reach the target, and allow X-rays to be emitted.

The anode is set at an angle to the electron beam

The face of the anode is set at an angle of about 70° to the axis joining the anode and cathode. The purpose of this is to provide a relatively large surface area to dissipate the energy of the electron beam, and a relatively small effective area as seen from the X-ray beam. A small focal spot size maximises the sharpness of the image in the radiograph.

The image below is of an X-ray tube that has been cut in half. The cathode (left) and anode (right) have been positioned so their internal surfaces are facing the viewer. The angled surface of the anode is visible through the hood.

Angled anode
(click photo to enlarge)
Photo of an Angled anode. Click to enlarge.
Effective focal spot size
Diagram - Origin of focal spot size from X-ray tube geometry

The heel effect is a reduction in intensity of radiation at the anode end of the X-ray beam

The radiation emitted from the anode has maximum intensity along a line at about 10° forward of the centre-line of the beam. The intensity diminishes as you move away from this plane.

Furthermore, at the anode side of the beam, some X-rays are absorbed by the target itself. This results in a greater fall-off in intensity at this end of the beam and is known as the heel effect.

Heel effect
Diagram - the heel effect.

The practical effect of this is small and will generally not be noticed in normal industrial radiographic exposures.

Back To Top


The X-ray Tube

Traditional X-ray tubes are made from borosilicate glass which may include a beryllium window

In the traditional X-ray tube, the anode and cathode are mounted in a borosilicate glass envelope that hermetically seals the tube to maintain the high level of internal vacuum.

In some X-ray tubes, the glass envelope contains a ‘window’ made from the metal beryllium. The purpose of this window is to allow a greater proportion of low energy X-rays to pass through the tube. This is particularly important for tubes that operate from a low voltage, and so produce a higher proportion of low-energy X-rays.

The glass envelope contains silicon and will absorb some low energy X-rays. Silicon has the atomic number 14 in the periodic table of elements. Beryllium has an atomic number 4 and is the lightest solid stable element in the periodic table. Beryllium absorbs much less of the low energy X-rays than silicon. A photograph of an X-ray tube is shown below.

X-ray tube
(click photo to enlarge)
Photo of an X-ray tube. Click to enlarge.

Metal-ceramic tubes are now being used in X-ray equipment

A more recent development in X-ray tube construction is the metal-ceramic tube, which is made from a steel cylinder brazed to alumina ceramic insulators at each end. These insulators carry the anode and cathode assemblies. The metal-ceramic tubes are smaller and more robust than their glass equivalents. They have another advantage, in that they enable more flexibility in the electrical circuitry associated with the tube.

Back To Top


X-ray Circuits

There are three basic methods of wiring an X-ray tube

The three basic methods of wiring an X-ray tube are:

Many industrial X-ray tubes are centre grounded, meaning that for a tube operating at 200 kV, the cathode is at -100 kV and the anode at +100 kV, giving a total potential difference of 200 kV between cathode and anode. This arrangement allows for lighter electricals and insulation to be used, resulting in greater portability. It has been used satisfactorily up to about 400 kV equipment, but provides problems for equipment operating above this voltage. This arrangement is also known as a bi-polar tube.

Negative grounding is rarely used as it provides no particular advantage. In a negative grounded 200 kV set, the cathode is at earth (zero) potential and the anode operates at +200 kV.

Positive grounding does provide an advantage. A positive grounded 200 kV set has the cathode operating at -200 kV and the anode is at earth (zero) potential. With the anode at ground potential, it can be water cooled because the pipes carrying the water will be at earth potential. This improves the efficiency of heat extraction, enabling higher currents and smaller focal spot sizes to be used. Negative and positive grounding arrangements are known as unipolar tubes.

X-ray circuits are powered from the AC supply

Because all X-ray tubes operate from an alternating current (AC) supply, the voltage on the tube is continually varying from positive, through zero, to negative 50 times each second due to Australia’s 50 Hertz supply.

Sine curve voltage vs. time
Diagram - The AC voltage of an X-ray tube (shown as the sine curve) plotted against time.

This gives rise to two effects:

  1. The speed of the electron striking the anode is a function of tube voltage. As the voltage varies, so will the energy of the electron as it strikes the anode. This contributes to the ‘white’ or continuous spectrum of X-ray wavelengths emitted from an X-ray tube. The shortest wavelength emitted is a function of the maximum voltage applied to the tube, and is given by the Duane-Hunt Law which states that “the wavelength of greatest intensity is approximately twice that of the shortest wavelength emitted”. The minimum wavelength generated is given by the equation below:
shortest wavelength equals 1.23 times 10 to the pwoer of minus 6 divided by applied voltage

Where:

For example, 200 kV the minimum wavelength (λ0) is 1.23 × 10-6 / 200,000 = 6.2 × 10-12 m.

  1. The negative half-cycle can cause a reversal in the flow of electrons, an effect called ‘strike-back’, whereby electrons might flow from the anode back to the cathode. This will damage the X-ray tube and must be avoided. A process of ‘rectification’ of the voltage supply is used to ensure that the voltage across the tube is always in one direction. The simplest type of rectification uses only half of the waveform, and the resulting waveform is called "half-wave rectified". More efficient is full-wave rectification, where both halves of the original waveform are utilised. The diagram below shows these waveforms. The positive and negative halves are coloured to show the effects of half-wave and full-wave rectification.
Waveforms used to drive X-ray tubes
Diagram - A diagram of all the different waveforms used to drive X-ray tubes.

There are several different circuits used in X-ray equipment to provide this rectification of the voltage.

The self rectified circuit is the simplest

In this circuit, no specific external rectification is provided. The X-ray tube itself provides rectification because normally electrons cannot escape from the cathode during the negative half cycle. If the anode is overheated however, electrons can escape, and strike-back will occur. Its advantage is lightness due to the absence of heavy rectification components. This is used only in smaller portable equipment as it has significant voltage and current limitations due to the thermal restraints at the anode.

Self rectified circuit

prompt iconClick "Start" to begin the demonstration.

Demonstration of a self rectified circuit.

Primary rectified circuit (Kearsley circuit) has a rectifier in the primary power supply

The Kearsley circuit has been used in X-ray sets operating up to 250 kV. A diode suppressor circuit, it reduces the high voltage applied to the tube during the negative half-cycle. The diode, typically a gas rectifier, is designed to carry a heavy current. It has a low resistance in the forward direction and consequently there is little or no drop in primary voltage across the diode on the conducting cycle, and the high-tension transformer delivers its normal load voltage. On the inverse half-cycle, the primary current is carried by the resistance, across which there is a large voltage drop. There is less primary voltage applied to the transformer and a lower voltage is applied to the X-ray tube on the inverse or no-load half-cycle.

Primary rectified circuit

prompt iconClick "Start" to begin the demonstration.

Demonstration of a primary rectified circuit.

Technical Note

Half wave rectified circuit has a rectifier in the secondary (high voltage) power circuit

This is a simple circuit in which the rectification is in the secondary (high voltage) circuit. This completely eliminates the inverse voltage applied to the tube. However, the rectifier must be capable of handling voltages in the megavolt range.

Half wave circuit

prompt iconClick "Start" to begin the demonstration.

Demonstration of a half-wave rectified circuit.

In all of the above circuits, the X-ray tube is effectively turned off for 50% of its operating time during the negative half cycle of the power supply.

Full wave rectified circuit (Graetz circuit) doubles the output of X-rays

The Graetz circuit, reverses the negative half cycle so that both halves of the alternating wave are used. Thus the idle time of the above circuits is removed and the X-ray output is effectively doubled. Its disadvantage is the requirement of four rectifiers connected in a form of Wheatstone bridge circuit. This makes for a bulky and heavy instrument that is suitable for a permanent installation only.

Graetz circuit and waveform

prompt iconClick "Start" to begin the demonstration.

Demonstration of a full-wave rectified circuit (or Graetz circuit).

Voltage doubling circuit (Villard circuit) is the most common circuit for industrial X-ray equipment

The rectifying valve, the high-tension capacitor, the high-tension transformer, and the tube filament transformer are all housed in a single oil-filled tank. The peak voltage between the tube cathode and anode is twice the peak voltage generated by the transformer. Two of these units connected to a shielded, centre-grounded X-ray tube form the basis of many 200-300 kV X-ray sets.

Consider the polarity such that the rectifier conducts. During this initial half-cycle the capacitor charges and the small voltage drop across it appears as inverse voltage on the X-ray tube. As the transformer voltage falls the capacitor supplies current to the tube and its voltage falls by a small amount, dependent on its capacity and the tube current; at the end of this half-cycle the transformer reverses polarity; its voltage is added to the capacitor voltage, and current is maintained through the tube while the voltage across it builds up to a maximum at the crest of this half-wave; it falls again at the next reversal of polarity of the transformer.

In subsequent action the capacitor voltage is alternately supplemented and reduced by the transformer voltage, and hence the voltage applied to the tube is sinusoidal, varying from 0 to 2 × V, where V is the peak voltage of the transformer. The rectifier valve must be capable of handling twice the tube voltage, which makes for a very heavy voltage requirement.

Villard circuit and waveform

prompt iconClick "Start" to begin the demonstration.

Demonstration of a voltage doubling circuit (or Villard circuit).

The constant potential circuit (Greinacher circuit)

One disadvantage of all of the above circuits, including the Villard circuit, is that the applied voltage has a sinusoidal waveform. In these circuits, the spectrum of the emitted X-rays contains a high proportion of low energy photons and the maximum intensity occurs at photon energies corresponding to about 0.6 of the peak voltage applied to the tube.

A constant potential applied to the X-ray tube results in no idle-time and a lower proportion of low energy photons in the emitted X-ray beam and a maximum emission corresponding to about 0.76 of the peak applied voltage. As a result, the same applied AC voltage gives both a higher output, and X-rays of slightly greater penetration, reducing the exposure times. Constant potential operation imposes greater stresses on the X-ray tube. This circuit is now used extensively in industrial X-ray sets operating up to 400 kV.

Greinacher circuit and waveform

prompt iconClick "Start" to begin the demonstration.

Demonstration of constant potential circuit (or Greinacher circuit).

High frequency circuits provide much improved performance

The most recent development in X-ray generator circuits is the high frequency circuit, with radically improved performance, stability and reproducibility. These circuits depart from the 50 Hz frequencies of mains supply current to operate at high 12 kHz frequencies, using electronic circuitry and thyristor power inverters with metal-ceramic X-ray tubes. The output is an accurately monitored constant potential in kilovolts and a current in milliampere with less than 1.5% ripple in the tube voltage.

Back To Top


Electron Accelerators

High energy X-ray equipment is used for heavy sections of steel

X-ray radiography can be performed on thick steel sections if a high-energy source of X-rays is available. The most common is the linear accelerator, although other sources such as betatrons and Van de Graaff generators have also been used.

Linear accelerators use microwaves to accelerate the electron to the target

Linear accelerators, or linacs, operate at energies ranging from 1 million electron volts (MeV) to 25 MeV. They incorporate an electron gun (source of electrons) and a target. The electrons are accelerated towards the target by ‘surfing’ a high frequency electromagnetic wave (microwave) travelling in a straight line through a tube known as a wave guide. The electrons ‘ride on the front of the wave’ just as a surfer rides a wave. As the microwave is travelling at the speed of light, and as the electron is a particle, it will slip over one crest and be picked up by the next wave. The electrons are accelerated to an energy of perhaps 5 million electron volts (5 MeV). X-rays are emitted from the far side of the target, the side opposite that struck by the electrons, in a narrow beam with very high intensity. Because of the high energies, these X-rays can deeply penetrate and may be used to radiograph steel of 300 mm and greater thickness.

Linear Accelerator

prompt iconClick "Start" to begin the demonstration. Roll your mouse over each red numbered bullet to read the labels.

Demonstration of a linear accelerator.

The betatron accelerates electrons in a toroidal vacuum chamber

The betatron is a donut shaped (toroidal) machine incorporating a number of electromagnets around an evacuated chamber. Electrons are injected from an electron gun and accelerated using an alternating magnetic field. This acceleration continues as the electrons pass many orbits around the chamber until they reach their required velocity, at which stage, they are released to strike the target with energies typically ranging from 15 MeV to 30 MeV. The output of X-rays from the betatron is much lower than that from linacs. As such, they have not achieved success as a commercial sources of high energy X-rays.

Betatron

prompt iconClick "Start" to begin the demonstration. Roll your mouse over each red numbered bullet to read the labels.

Demonstration of a betatron accelerator.

Van de Graaff generators use an electrostatic source of energy

The Van de Graaff generator accumulates large amounts of static charge. The principle is the same as that used to ‘charge’ a plastic ruler by rubbing it vigorously over a woolen fabric such as a pullover. The charge on the belt is discharged through a conducting comb. These devices usually operate at around 1 MeV to 3 MeV with very low currents. Their advantages include a true constant potential and very small (0.1 mm) focal spot size. Their limitations include a low intensity of X-rays and a very bulky installation required to generate the electric energy.

Van de Graaff Generator

prompt icon Roll your mouse over each red numbered bullet to read the labels.

A diagram of a Van de Graaf generator.

Back To Top


Check Your Progress

  1. The three basic requirements for an X-ray tube are:
    1. A source of electrons, a high voltage and a low voltage.
    2. A source of electrons, a means of accelerating the electrons and a target.
    3. A glass envelope, a vacuum and a high voltage.
    4. An anode, a cathode and an evacuated tube.

    Answer: b - A source of electrons, a means of accelerating the electrons and a target.

  2. The anode in an X-ray tube is aligned:
    1. parallel to the direction of electron flow.
    2. at right angles to the direction of electron flow.
    3. at about 70° to the direction of electron flow.
    4. at about 45° to the direction of electron flow.

    Answer: c - At about 70° to the direction of the electron flow.

  3. The fall off in intensity of an X-ray beam towards the anode end of the beam is known as:
    1. Heel effect
    2. Anode effect
    3. Heel and toe syndrome
    4. X-ray degradation

    Answer: a - Heel effect

  4. The purpose of a Beryllium window in some X-ray tubes is:
    1. To allow electrons to be emitted
    2. To allow harder X-rays to be emitted
    3. To prevent emission of harder X-rays
    4. To allow softer X-rays to be emitted

    Answer: d - To allow softer X-rays to be emitted

  5. An advantage of a positive grounded (earthed) uni-polar X-Ray tube is:
    1. It allows for direct cooling of the anode
    2. It allows for direct cooling of the cathode
    3. It provides harder more penetrating x-rays
    4. It enables the use of lighter electrical systems

    Answer: a - It allows for direct cooling of the anode

  6. Many portable X-ray tubes are bi-polar. This is because this method of wiring:
    1. enables lighter electrical transformers to be used.
    2. provides the most efficient means of generating X-rays.
    3. filters out the more easily scattered low energy X-rays.
    4. is the cheapest system for manufacturing X-ray tube heads.

    Answer: a - Enables lighter electrical transforms to be used.

  7. Name 2 different X-ray tube circuits and briefly describe their advantages and limitations.

    Answer: Refer to X-ray Circuits for a description of X-ray tube circuits.

  8. In a linear accelerator, the electrons are accelerated towards the target using:
    1. very high voltages
    2. an electron blaster
    3. microwaves
    4. cosmic rays

     Answer: c - microwaves

Back To Top


Your Task

Click here to open the answer sheet for this task.

  1. Research on the Internet for manufacturers of industrial X-ray equipment, both portable and stationary. Report the kilovolt and milliampere ranges of these machines, and where possible report the grounding type, and the circuit type.
  2. You have two X-ray radiographs taken of the same item under similar conditions, but with different X-ray tubes. The radiographs were taken with the same test specimen, film type, tube voltage, tube current, exposure time and source to film distance. The radiographs were processed together. Nevertheless, the radiographs had different average densities (degree of blackness). Try to suggest reasons why the densities would be different. Discuss this topic with the other students at the forum.

Back To Top